Draft Communications Data Bill cannot proceed - Nick Clegg
Government plans to give police and intelligence services new powers to monitor email and internet use need a "fundamental rethink", Nick Clegg (photo) says. The deputy PM said he would block the draft Communications Data Bill and push for plans that got "the balance between security and liberty right". His comments came as a committee of MPs and peers criticised the bill's scope, according BBC News. The Home Office said the new laws were needed "without delay" to stop serious crimes such as terrorism. Under the plans, internet service providers would have to store details of all online communication in the UK, such as the time, duration, originator and recipient of a communication and the location of the device from which it was made.
However, police would need a warrant to be able to see the content of any messages.
A report from the Joint Committee on the Draft Communications Bill accepted there was a need for new legislation to help the police fight crime and tackle security threats organised via online communications.
But it warned that ministers would be able to demand "limitless categories of data" on internet communications if the draft bill was not amended.
Right to privacy
It called for "safeguards" over the new powers to prevent abuse.
The committee also accused the government of producing estimates of the cost of implementing the bill that were not "robust" enough.
"The figure for estimated benefits is even less reliable than that for costs, and the estimated net benefit figure is fanciful and misleading," it said.
The MPs and peers added: "We believe that the draft bill pays insufficient attention to the duty to respect the right to privacy."
The legislation "goes much further than it need or should for the purpose of providing necessary and justifiable official access to communications data", their report said.
Mr Clegg, the Liberal Democrat leader, said the committee had raised "a number of serious criticisms - not least on scope, proportionality, cost, checks and balances, and the need for much wider consultation".
"It is for those reasons that I believe the coalition government needs to have a fundamental rethink about this legislation. We cannot proceed with this bill and we have to go back to the drawing board."
But he added: "The committee did not, however, suggest that nothing needs to be done. They were very clear that there is a problem that must be addressed to give law enforcement agencies the powers they need to fight crime. I agree.
"But that must be done in a proportionate way that gets the balance between security and liberty right."
Home Secretary Theresa May has said the plans are needed to help society fight crime and "save lives", and that the police would be able to see the details of communications only if they had a "clear case" and investigative justification. She wants the bill in place next year.
The committee said the home secretary would be given "sweeping powers to issue secret notices to communications service providers (CSPs) requiring them to retain and disclose potentially limitless categories of data".
But it added: "We have been told that she has no intention of using the powers in this way. Our main recommendation is therefore that her powers should be limited to those categories of data for which a case can now be made."
If these powers needed to be enhanced in future, this should be done with "effective parliamentary scrutiny", it said.
The Intelligence and Security Committee, a separate committee of MPs and peers that reports directly to the prime minister, said there had been a "lack of coherent communication" on the "safeguards that will be in place" under the bill.
It said it accepted there was "a serious problem that requires action", but added Parliament and the public would require more information if they were to be convinced by the proposals.
Civil liberties campaigners have described the proposals as a "snooper's charter".
Rachel Robinson from Liberty said: "These are blanket proposals which apply to every one of us in this country, large databases of information about all of our web habits, and that's simply too high a price to pay."
But the Child Exploitation and Online Protection (Ceop) agency has said that the powers will make it easier to convict paedophiles and murderers.
A Home Office spokesman said: "This legislation is vital to help catch paedophiles, terrorists and other serious criminals and we are pleased both scrutiny committees have recognised the need for new laws.
"We have now considered the committees' recommendations carefully and we will accept the substance of them all. But there can be no delay to this legislation. It is needed by law enforcement agencies now."
Apasa aici pentru a trimite e-mail!
Alte articole similare
- More time online, with the Connect 3G special offers from COSMOTE ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- Deloitte announces new application session in the EU Gateway program ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- Google Maps native iPhone app launched on Apple's store ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- US, UK and Canada refuse to sign UN's internet treaty ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- Apple v Samsung: Judge rejects Apple plea for sales ban ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- ‘RadarMe powered by COSMOTE’, the app that lets you chat and know where your friends are ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- EC names broadband top digital priority for 2013 ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- Small Cells Expected to Carve a Niche in Public Venues, Worth $3.1 Billion by 2018 ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- The latest communication campaign from COSMOTE - 'Something new every day, so you have things to talk about' ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- COSMOTE Romania continues the Custom of Love campaign, now at its 5th edition ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- Mobile networks braced for 'busiest ever' New Year surge ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- Cyber thieves pose as Google+ social network ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- Google head and former US governor in North Korea visit ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- CES 2013 - Sony unveils bath-friendly Xperia Z smartphone ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- Nokia's India factory raided by tax officials ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- Amazon AutoRip service gives out free digital copies of CDs ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- Microsoft to turn off Windows Messenger on 15 March ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- Facebook unveils social search tools for users ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- COSMOTE launches first Intel-based smartphone in Romania, ZTE Grand X In ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- US plants hit by USB stick malware attack ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- ZyXEL primește recunoasterea “Taiwan Excellence” ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- Facebook adds free calling feature for US iPhones ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- Nokia backs 3D printing for mobile phone cases ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- Sony Xperia Z tablet and LG Optimus Pro G phone unveiled ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- Lack of long-term, disciplined policies threatens to worsen sovereign debt woes - KPMG Report ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- Microsoft profit dips despite Windows 8 sales boost ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- 43.2 Mbps speeds with the new modem from Cosmote and enhanced mobile data tariff plans ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- US phone unlocking deadline set to expire ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- Smartphone sensors reveal security secrets ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- Verizon Wireless 4G LTE Mobile Hotspot MiFi 5510L ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- Microsoft launches Office 2013 software suite ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- Blackberry 10 handset to launch first in the UK ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- Samsung gains tablet market share as Apple lead narrows ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- Twitter: Hackers target 250,000 users ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- COSMOTE Romania celebrates Safer Internet Day 2013 for the fifth year in a row ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- Liberty Global to buy Virgin Media for USD 23 bln ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- Rupert Murdoch tweets Chinese 'still hacking' WSJ ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- Vodafone Romania reports the financial results for the third quarter ended December 31, 2012 ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- Ben Verwaayen resigns as CEO of Alcatel-Lucent ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- Alcatel-Lucent board struggles to find CEO to replace Verwaayen ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- Vertu chooses Android over Windows for luxury handset ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- Samsung v Apple phones ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- Apple loses Brazilian iPhone trademark ruling ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- COSMOTE steps forward to the new communication era empowered by 4G technology ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- COSMOTE Romania launches ‘COSMOTE My Tab’, the first tablet under own brand ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- Facebook was targeted by 'sophisticated' hackers ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- Bill Gates: We Blew It In Mobile ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )
- P3 communications - Vodafone Romania has been certified for its performance of the web browsing services on smartphones ( de COMUNIC@ŢII Mobile )